COUNTRY VIGNETTES | Brazil
COUNTRY VIGNETTES | Brazil
Introduction - Brazil
As part of the STRiDE project, we developed five case vignettes to explore access to diagnosis, care and support for people living with dementia and their families. These case vignettes provide useful insights into how people living with dementia and their family carers can access diagnosis, care and support, and can navigate the systems in place; they also highlight what barriers people are likely to encounter.
Each of the vignettes portrays different characteristics and living situations. A detailed overview of the approach taken can be found here. In addition to the five case vignettes (01-05) that the STRiDE teams across the seven countries applied to their country-specific context, the teams created additional case vignettes that represent scenarios particularly relevant to their context.
Below we outline, based on available evidence and expert advice, the likely access (or not) to diagnosis, care and support in each country for the illustrated cases.
23 Mar 2022
Mrs A and her family, current experience - Brazil
Even though Mrs. Amélia does not like to go to the community health centre (primary care unit), her daughter would try to convince her to make an appointment with a doctor. Possibly, she would take her mother to a traditional healer before taking her to a doctor. Given her mother’s reluctance to go to the community health centre, it is likely that being seen by a traditional healer would be more well accepted by Mrs. Amélia.
Another possibility would be that Mrs. Amélia’s daughter and family would think Mrs. Amélia’s strange behaviour was part of a natural ageing process, so no further action would be taken to investigate her condition. However, supposing that an appointment with a doctor had been made, the consultation could happen in a primary care unit with or without the Family Health Strategy Program, depending on where they live.
The Family Health Strategy is the cornerstone of the primary healthcare system in Brazil, the program aims to expand, qualify and consolidate the delivery of healthcare to the population according to the precepts of SUS and involves healthcare teams that delivery person-centred care in the communities. The program currently covers about 62% of the Brazilian population. It is possible that after the first consultation with a GP, Mrs. Amélia would be referred to a specialist (neurologist, geriatrician or psychiatrist) who would establish or not the diagnosis of dementia. Not all doctors are well trained to diagnose dementia in Brazil.
A less likely possibility in a small village, would be that her family would take her to a private doctor (out of pocket or private insurance) in a big city. However, this would require more family support such as dealing with logistics, travel costs, consultation costs, etc. Her daughter would likely be the person taking on this role.
Assuming Mrs. Amélia had been diagnosed and had access to a family health team, the doctor would probably say to Mrs. Amélia’s family that Mrs. Amélia has memory issues and that these are a ‘normal’ part of ageing, even though a medication that is specific for dementia would likely be prescribed. Mrs. Amélia would probably have access to her medication free of charge via SUS (the Brazil’s Universal Health System) even if the consultation was with a private doctor. However, it might happen that for getting the medication free of charge, Mrs. Amélia’s daughter would need to travel to a health unit located in a larger city. It is likely that the doctor who gave her the diagnosis, as well as the family health team, would become the key professionals to support Mrs. Amélia with her needs.
Besides, she would make use of clinical services from the secondary level of care too. However, Mrs. Amélia or her family would not likely be referred to any psychosocial advice or support services in the community. As a note, it is possible that by the time Mrs. Amélia had finally been diagnosed with dementia, her symptoms would have worsened and she would probably be in a more advanced stage of the disease.
As Mrs. Amélia lives with her husband and nearby her daughter, this living arrangement is likely to be kept for a while until Mrs. Amélia and her husband’s independence start to be compromised. In such a case, her daughter would progressively become the main caregiver for Mrs. Amélia, meaning she would probably end up leaving her job at some point to take care of her mother. This situation could bring financial constrains to the life of Mrs. Amélia’s daughter as there is no payment cash transference by the government for informal/familiar carer in Brazil.
Unfortunately, it is likely that family members would not have enough information regarding dementia and so would probably not get involved with supporting Mrs. Amélia and her daughter. Information and emotional support for people with dementia and their carers can be delivered free of charge by NGOs, but these associations are not common in rural areas or even in urban areas. Thus, many people lack this kind of support and feel themselves even more burdened. People generally access the NGO services when they are “luck enough” to be told about the existence of them or when they discover the associations through searches in the internet. Public health campaigns are also meant to deliver information and support on dementia, but these campaigns are rare too.
Stigma is frequently experienced by people living with dementia and their family/carers in Brazil. Stigma can be specially observed in rural Brazil where, generally, not enough information on dementia is available. People tend to face the disease as a normal stage of ageing or as madness and there is a sense that nothing can be done for the person living with dementia and her family. Mrs. Amélia’s daughter would probably notice that friends and family members would gradually stop visiting them and would not use the term “dementia” to refer to her mother’s health condition. On the other hand, in a rural area people generally know each other and a sense of welcome and empathy might be built, resulting in less stigma and more support to Mrs. Amélia and her family.
13 Nov 2021
Mrs B and her family, current experience - Brazil
It has been two years since Mrs. Beatriz changed behaviour and has not been taken to a doctor. This means she might have never been taken to a consultation and, as the disease progresses, her nuclear family would just try to adapt themselves to the situation, somehow sharing Mrs. Beatriz’s care needs between them, but without expecting any support from the community or extended family. However, there is still a chance her family would take Mrs. Beatriz to a free consultation with a general practitioner (GP) who is part of the SUS (universal health system) or would take her to be consulted with a private doctor (out of pocket or institution private insurance). In any of the cases, Mrs. Beatriz could be diagnosed or not, as many doctors still have no special training in dementia, even in mid-size towns in Brazil. Therefore, she might have received the diagnosis with some delay.
After being properly diagnosed with dementia, Mrs. Beatriz would be prescribed medication that is accessible free of charge via SUS at the point of access. Although SUS offers non-medical treatment such as physiotherapy, phono audiology etc. it is unlikely she would be referred to these treatments given a possible lack of knowledge by doctors (for instance) that might not associate these treatments with helping people living with dementia. Mrs. Beatriz could also have access to therapies through healthcare insurance or paying for them privately.
If Mrs. Beatriz lives in a region covered by the family health strategy, some professionals such as doctors, nurses, dentists, physiotherapists and community health workers could provide information and sporadic support (e.g. home visits once a month to follow up on specific issues) to Mrs. Beatriz, however the government would not provide her with formal carers or any other human resources for the day-to-day care. Unless Mrs. Beatriz’s family decided and managed to get one of the few places in a long-term care home (probably a philanthropic or private one as the public ones are nearly non-existent), Mrs. Beatriz would probably continue to live at her son’s house for a long time.
Mrs. Beatriz’s wider family could give some sporadic help, but normally, the day-to-day chores and care would be provided by her nuclear family (mainly by her daughter-in-law). Mrs. Beatriz’s limiting condition would increase her family’s worry regarding her health and would require more time spent to meet her caring needs, resulting in a more stressful routine to Mrs. Beatriz’s daughter-in-law and less time dedicated to the family business. As time goes by, Mrs. Beatriz’s daughter-in-law would probably have to reduce her activities in the family business to spend more time caring for Mrs. Beatriz and the house. This could restrict the family income as there is no payment cash transference program in such cases by the government. Another option would be to pay for a carer for Mrs. Beatriz so that her daughter-in-law would not be at risk of stopping to work in the family business. However, paying for a carer can be very expensive in Brazil and Mrs. Beatriz’s. family probably would not be able to afford it.
Although it is not a regular behaviour from family members in Brazil, Mrs. Beatriz’s family members could get advice about dementia through some older people’s association, family health strategy team or community health centres (as they might exist in the town). Some of these services could be accessed free of charge through SUS. It is possible that Mrs. Beatriz and her family would experience stigma and lack of support from their friends and other family members. It is likely that Mrs. Beatriz’s nuclear family would be judge by other family members in case they decided to move Mrs. Beatriz to a long-term care home. Not much support would be available from their relatives regarding daily care tasks, as they might feel impatient when dealing with Mrs. Beatriz.
15 Nov 2021
Mrs C and her family, current experience - Brazil
Mrs. Claudia may or may not be taken by her family to a public health doctor, a private doctor, or a doctor from a health insurance for assessment and diagnosis. In some cases, such as Mrs. Claudia, the family may think the symptoms are a normal part of ageing and will look after her needs as these appear, never taking her to a clinician for a proper assessment. In some cases, medical doctors may also not be prepared to diagnose or may also think this is a normal ‘senile issue’, and so Mrs. Claudia would stay without a diagnosis. This situation could result in poor care and support to Mrs. Claudia and could cause family disarrangements due to lack of understanding about the dementia symptoms.
In Brazil, the delivery of health is organised in three levels of care: the primary care level – that is the gateway for accessing SUS, promoting education, evaluation and disease-risk reduction among families –, the secondary level of care which includes specialist care services, and the tertiary level of care which includes high-complexity procedures and hospitals. If the primary level health care doctor suspected dementia, Mrs. Claudia would then be referred to the secondary level healthcare team (neurologist, psychiatrist or geriatrician) to establish diagnosis (with extra exams if needed) and pharmacological treatment. If these specialists are well trained for this, Mrs Claudia would then receive a diagnosis, pharmacological treatment, and would continue to be assessed periodically by the secondary care team.
Mrs. Claudia’s family (as well as neighbours and friends, if any) will likely to be the only source of support available for Mrs. Claudia, both financially (if Mrs. Claudia income is insufficient to pay for her own needs) and on the day-to-day-care, unless they can pay for care services privately. A few branches of the Alzheimer’s Associations exist around the country which can provide information and emotional support; however, as a standard rule, no support is available freely with regards to the physical care or respite services for carers. Only a few care homes are available through government and religious associations around the country, meaning that Mrs. Claudia is likely to continue to be cared for at her family home until the end of her life.
There are home care services provided by the public health system, however very often these only include visits from professionals regarding healthcare/medical needs and not the care itself (feeding, bathing, etc.). If Mrs. Claudia’s family lives in an area covered by the family health strategy, the team might provide some help with specific care needs in advanced stages of dementia, such as in case the person is using a feeding tube or in case of pressure injury or other would dressing. The care provided by families is fully unpaid and there are no allowances for family carers. Mrs. Claudia would likely have a retirement pension and disability allowance could be provided in some cases.
The public health system offers health-care-related supplies in some cases (diapers, feeding tubes and enteral diet, materials for dressing wounds) and dementia medication is available freely through the SUS. Private services are expensive, mainstream private insurance usually do not cover continuous formal care, and dementia training is not common practice, meaning that the care received would probably not be ‘dementia friendly’.
People with dementia do experience stigma and are often disempowered. Lack of knowledge and awareness about dementia lead to late diagnosis, when people with dementia would no longer be capable of making decisions regarding their own care. Mrs. Claudia’s daughter would probably be very unsupported by her own family and employer, which would probably make her quit her job, furthering the financial strains on the family.
The absence of a systematised support system to support carers makes it likely that Mrs. Claudia’s daughter would also face stressful events and personal problems in her relationship with her own daughter given the restricted time they have to relax and enjoy each other’s company. It is unlikely that the family will have the option to put Mrs. Claudia in a care home, but if this become a possibility, it is likely that they will be judged by her own family and friends.
17 Nov 2021
Mr D and his family, current experience - Brazil
Mr. Diego would be entitled to a consultation with the general practitioner (medic) through SUS which provides universal healthcare that is free at point of access. However, it is unlikely that Mr. Diego would see a doctor by himself, he would need one of his children to take him to a medic consultation (regardless of being a consultation by the public or private health sector). Even in mid-size towns, general practitioners often do not have enough knowledge to diagnose dementia, so Mr. Diego could be at a later stage of dementia when diagnosis would formally be given (if any).
Mr. Diego would need to move in with his son or another family member to be assisted with his daily activities as no continuous care or support would be available for him at his own residence, unless he paid for it privately or via health insurance (the latter usually do not include day-to-day care).
Primary healthcare teams would provide visits for specific health needs, but long-term further care would need to be provided for by the family or privately. It is possible that in one of these visits, the primary care team would make a multidimensional assessment (to have a biopsychosocial diagnosis of Mr. Diego and identify his frailties) and develop a care plan to be performed together with his family. However, although this service is available, its implementation will depend a lot on the knowledge of the health team. Mr. Diego would probably become socially isolated and would not be encouraged to be independent.
It is very likely that Mr. Diego would experience stigma from neighbours or even from some family members as he could be excluded from meetings given to a possible “not socially accepted” behaviour. His son is already worried about what people may think of his father. Friends and neighbours may not be supportive and could judge Mr. Diego’s family for leaving him living at his own house, or in case they decided to pay for a long-term residential care home. Probably, a daughter or daughter-in-law would take responsibility over his care taking him to live with her and her family or moving in his house.
17 Nov 2021
Mr E and his family, current experience - Brazil
Mr. Elias’s work colleagues, company’s human resources sector, neighbours and friends, if any, would possibly be the ones to refer him to a consultation with a doctor at the public health system. It would take a while before Mr. Elias realised he himself would need an appointment to discuss his condition. After multiple appointments and a series of tests, he would probably be told not to worry about being forgetful and would be prescribed tablets to release the stress and depression of living alone.
Because many general practitioners often see dementia as a normal part of ageing, it is likely that Mr. Elias would be at a later stage of dementia when diagnosis would formally be given. At this stage, his safety would be compromised and his capacity to plan his own future would be diminished.
Although Mr. Elias’s work colleagues, neighbours and close friends (if any) could ask for advice and support through Alzheimer’s associations based in Curitiba or through online courses (some of them are paid ones), this scenario is not likely to happen as there is not enough information about these services for people in Brazil. Because there is no dementia-specific policy in Brazil, as well as limited access to free care homes, Mr. Elias would probably need primary care health professionals to refer him to social workers in order to either remediate his relationship with his family or to be placed in a public long term care institution.
Although it is a less likely possibility, Mr. Elias could try to contact one of his children. After knowing the health state of their dad, perhaps one of his children could ask Mr. Elias to live with one of them (in Brazil there is a tacit belief that children must support their older parents, besides this responsibility is also stated in the Brazilian Federal Constitution) or convince him to go to a public long term care institution in his hometown to be closer to their children (this possibility, however, may not exist). Another possibility would be Mr. Elias to be oriented to pay for a carer for himself, depending on his financial situation. Nonetheless, somebody would have to help him to deal with work regulations as his capacity diminishes with the progress of the disease.
Mr. Elias could experience stigma as people in the neighbourhood would probably start to note his different behaviour and could start to label and judge him and his family, in a way they would not be aware of. Unfortunately, the lack of information about dementia in the community may result in a lack of support from people in society.
17 Nov 2021
Mrs Fatima and her family, current experience - Brazil
Mrs. Fatima would be entitled to a consultation with the general practitioner (medic) through the public health system which provides universal healthcare that is free at point of access. However, general practitioners often do not have enough knowledge to diagnose dementia. In a remote setting such as the Amazon forest, the health priorities are likely to differ from a large Urban area, and health issues such as malaria, diarrhoea, and undernutrition, are likely to be prioritised over chronic conditions affecting older people. This is also partly due to the much smaller population of older people living in these communities.
Mrs. Fatima’s daughter would have difficulty in discussing her mother’s symptoms with the health care team due to language barrier and lack of understanding about what was exactly happening with her mom, which would probably lead to a deterioration of Mrs. Fatima’s health and wellbeing before any action could be taken by the health team, and this would delay the diagnosis considerably. Other symptoms of dementia, apart from hallucinations and aggressiveness, could not even been noted by Mrs. Fatima’s family given the lack of information about the condition. If the health team were actioned and suspected dementia, Mrs. Fatima and her daughter would need to travel by boat to a large city (such as Manaus) to go under further examination and tests. Several months would past and several trips to the big city would be necessary for Mrs. Fatima to be diagnosed.
If a diagnosis were made, the medication could be brought to Mrs. Fatima via the healthcare workers on their monthly visits. However, Mrs. Fatima would be unlikely to have access to psychosocial support or formal care mainly due to the remote area she lives in.
Mrs. Fatima’s daughter would slowly become her full-time carer, and probably little training and information would be available for her. Even if Mrs. Fatima’s family could pay for the long-term care, which would probably not be the case, service providers would not be available for her at the community she lives in. Mrs. Fatima would probably become more isolated as the disease progressed, and that would be both encouraged and accepted (as a sign of respect) by her family. Other senior tribe members would try to ‘cure’ Mrs. Fatima with natural medicines and other healing practices, which would make Mrs. Fatima more anxious and angrier. Though Mrs. Fatima is highly respected in her community, people could be afraid of her behaviour due to the belief that this was caused by malevolent spirits. However, another possibility would be that people in the community would take care of Mrs. Fatima and supervise her when she was walking around the community. This could minimize the chance of Mrs. Fatima getting lost and contribute to keep her independence as she could go to the river to wash her belongings, for example.
17 Nov 2021
Mr Gabriel and his family, current experience - Brazil
Mr. Gabriel would probably continue in this situation for a little while and his symptoms would be faced as normal part of ageing until his son or daughter-in-law noticed something that called their attention, such as serious memory loss (e.g. forgetting the oven on). Mr. Gabriel’s several health issues would likely mask his dementia symptoms and professionals would probably say that his symptoms are due to side effects of the medication in use or to his blood sugar levels.
Healthcare provision is free of charge at the point of use, and family visits are commonly provided by the primary healthcare teams. However due to the difficulty in access, the community healthcare team would tend to visit less often that area and the communication between Mr. Gabriel and his GP would probably be made through his son, who would likely be busy working full time in the city. Mr. Gabriel’s son or his daughter-in-law would also collect his medication monthly free of charge at the primary healthcare unit.
Once Mr. Gabriel’s family or health team noticed his symptoms, Mr. Gabriel would be taken for an appointment with the GP at the health centre, or a community health agent would arrange a visit of the family health team, where Mr. Gabriel would be examined. If the GP suspected of dementia, Mr. Gabriel would then be referred to a specialist as part of the secondary care system. Several months are likely to pass before Mr. G can be assessed by the specialist, who would do the neuropsychological assessment and would ask for further exams. The entire process to diagnosis is likely to take over a year. During this period, Mr. Gabriel is likely to be “supervised” by a neighbour in the absence of his family. Another possibility is that his daughter in law may decide to quit her job to stay with Mr. Gabriel. Nonetheless, this might not be an option due to the financial burden this decision could pose on her family, so it is likely that Mr. Gabriel’s care would depend on neighbours or more distant family members or he would be left to his own care.
When Mr. Gabriel received his diagnosis (if any), they would access any specific medication free of charge through the “high-cost medication system”, which requires several documents and exams in order to have access. In terms of non-medical treatment, it is likely that he would not have access to any, given the believe that his symptoms were consequence from the natural ageing process.
Due to his difficulty in getting out and about outside his house, Mr. Gabriel would likely continue to be isolated in his own community, and his dementia and other co-morbidities would deteriorate quite fast. Another possibility is that the family health team would visit Mr. Gabriel once a month, but the focus of the consultation would be his symptoms, medication, and physical care, with little support or information on the psychosocial aspects of his daily life.
Mr. Gabriel would probably be cared for by his daughter-in-law until his death, through which time he would be on and off the hospital for several infections and other health issues. As Mr. Gabriel became more and more dependent, the health team would decide (without the family involvement in the decision process) to use a feeding tube to feed Mr. Gabriel. He would also be using diaper quite early in the process, which would increase his risks for UTI infection. The diapers would be provided to Mr. Gabriel free of charge by the SUS.
The family finances would become deeply affected by Mr. Gabriel daughter-in-law’s possible unemployment and Mr. Gabriel’s care costs. She would face a lot of the complex health needs of Mr. G with very little support (if any). She would become depressed and would probably not look after her own health during the period she provided care to her father-in-law.
17 Nov 2021
Mr Hugo and his family, current experience - Brazil
Mr. Hugo has a private health insurance and have regular health checks with his geriatrician. Once his wife convinced Mr Hugo. to go for an appointment with his geriatrician, they would easily be able to book an appointment for the next week or so. The clinic he normally goes is close by and Mr. Hugo and his wife can go by car. The geriatrician would do a neuropsychiatric assessment and would refer Mr. Hugo for further exams, such as a CT scan. Mr. Hugo would not need to wait very long for these, and if so, he would be able to pay for it privately. In few weeks or months Mr. Hugo would return to his doctor and a diagnosis would be given. Another possibility is that because of his reluctance in seeing a doctor, by the time Mr. Hugo had finally accepted to seek a consultation, his dementia symptoms would have advanced.
His doctor would say that his symptoms are a typical problem with older adults and that he should just go home, live his life as usual, and “follow up” from time to time. However, he would forbid Mr. Hugo from driving. Mr. Hugo would become depressed and would have trouble to make sense of his condition.
His wife would try to do everything for him, which would make him feel even more incapable. After taking the doctor’s letter to the Human Resource (HR) Department at his place of employment/work, Mr. Hugo would be “invited” to take an early retirement. As Mr. Hugo became more dependent, the housemaid would become to help him with his daily tasks more and more. Mr. Hugo’s wife would try and hire a home care worker, to which Mr. Hugo would probably be resistant to.
At some point Mr. Hugo cannot decide for himself anymore, and home care workers (paid for by the family) would come and stay full time caring for Mr. Hugo. He would only go to his geriatrician/psychiatrist only once in a while for to adjust his medication. As Mrs. Hugo’s dementia advanced, the domiciliary healthcare team would start visiting him for nursing, nutritionist, and physiotherapist care and assessments. All the care, however, is very focused on Mr. Hugo physical care needs, and little about promoting his independence.
Mr. Hugo’s children rarely visit and people they knew stopped visiting. His wife is retired and has her own health issues. She feels very isolated and miss having more intimacy with her husband as her house appears to have become a hospital – full of health professionals coming and going, hospital bed, diapers, etc. She is suffering from anticipated grief and she misses the husband she once knew. They had many dreams for their retirement, but now she feels like she’s lost all of that. She feels that she is expected to cope and feels very lonely. However, the domiciliary care team or doctors have never asked her how she feels or what her needs are. In addition to that, they live in a house with stairs and she is faced with the decision of moving somewhere else so that her husband can leave their bedroom. Even with all these difficulties and feelings, Mr. Hugo’s wife has never considered moving him to a residential as these institutions are very stigmatised in Brazil.
17 Nov 2021
Mrs Silva and her family, current experience - Brazil
Mrs. Silva would probably already be linked to the secondary care system (in the urban area) due to her previous stroke. Her daughter would bring the memory symptoms up during one of her appointments and the neurologist would probably be trained to suspect dementia. Mrs. Silva and her daughter would have to do several trips to the main city for the clinical investigation, for which the farm owners would take her, or the municipality would send an adapted car through the social care system whenever she had an appointment, or Mrs. Silva or the farm owners would pay for a taxi privately.
The diagnosis is likely to take several months due to the need to wait for CT scans and other tests. Mrs. Silva would probably be prescribed anti-psychotic medication or another sedative medicine so she could be ‘easier to handle’. Mrs. Silva’s daughter might have access to carer’ groups at the outpatient clinic, but that is not a mainstream service, so one of her main unmet needs would be information about dementia and care. Besides, even if she had access to a carer’s group, living in a remote rural area could prevent her of participating in such activities.
Depending on the distance from the house, the primary healthcare team would visit Mrs. Silva every so often to check on her situation. These visits would probably be focused on the physical and clinical needs of Mrs. Silva, rather than supporting Mrs. Silva’s daughter with the care.
Mrs. Silva and her daughter could receive financial support from the farm owner or not. Mrs. Silva daughter would be entitled to disability allowance. They would be entitled to receiving diapers, wound dressing materials, medicines, and skin care. Due to the long distance to the city, it is possible that no private care provider would accept to provide care services at the farm, and all the care responsibilities would indeed fall on Mrs. Silva daughter’s shoulder. Mrs. Silva’s other male children would not help with the care.
Mrs. Silva would be hospitalised several times throughout the years due to complications of dysphagia and diaper use (e.g. pneumonia; UTI). As Mrs. Silva became more and more dependent, the health team would decide (without the family involvement in the decision process) to use a feeding tube to feed Mrs. Silva. This would further increase the complexity of Mrs. Silva’s care needs, as well as her daughter’s anxiety levels and poor sleep quality. Mrs. Silva would become less mobile and would likely develop ulcer pressures due to lack of training and equipment to prevent them.
17 Nov 2021
Mrs Jacqueline and her family, current experience - Brazil
Mrs. Jacqueline would probably be linked to a neurologist due to her previous stroke and her husband would be able to contact him\her directly to ask for an immediate home-based private consultation. The neurologist would provide a thorough assessment and would ask for exams. Mrs. Jacqueline and her husband would go to the main city with their driver to undergo further examination privately, which would be much faster than the mainstream care (public or via insurance). The neurologist would then diagnose Mrs. Jacqueline and would prescribe medication, which Mrs. Jacqueline’s husband would purchase in a local pharmacy monthly.
The neurologist would or would not refer Mrs Jacqueline. to other health professionals, such as a nutritionist or a nurse, for which they would pay privately. Mrs. Jacqueline’s husband would ask for a few of his female employees from the farm to begin support him with the house chores and direct care with Mrs. Jacqueline, however they would likely not receive any training for that. The professionals who Mrs. Jacqueline’s husband hired for private consultations would occasionally assist with specific training needs they may have.